Looking at Alva Noe’s Book (2023) “Entanglement” (Part 8 of 24)
0091 What is “entanglement”?
Dr. Noe paints with a broad brush. In many ways, he exercises the liberty of expertise. Experts can always use a technical term in such a manner as to effectively say, “Guess what I’m thinking.”
Typically, the broad brush is used in a semiotic (think Bible-like) style, where the expert is asking the layman to conceive of a possibility.
The narrow brush is used in Greek (think Socrates-like) style, where the expert is asking the layman to eliminate all possibilities other than the correct one.
0092 Razie Mah’s use of the term “entanglement” is according to the Greek style. Entanglement is not a substance, it is like an inversion of substance. Entanglement occurs when a form entangles other matter, thus increasing the contradictions inherent in the actuality of the thing.
0093 Now, I conduct a very quick overview of ideas that appear in Razie Mah’s blog under the title, Looking at Ian Hodder’s Book (2024) “Entangled”. The blogs are posted in October 2026. Hodder is an archaeologist who conducted excavations at Catal Hoyuk in Turkiye (Anatolia).
0094 First, what is a noumenon?
A noumenon is (theoretically) a thing.
0095 According to the first step in Aristotle’s natural philosophy, a thing is to be regarded as matter and form. That is the first abstraction. Aristotle’s hylomorphe (“the little noumenon”) exemplifies Peirce’s category of secondness. Consequently, Aristotle’s thing serves as an actuality2a in a category-based nested form. Mariusz Tabaczek’s 2025 review of classical and contemporary hylomorphism inspires the naming of a content-level normal context3a and potential1a as follows.

0096 The form2af in the little noumenon entangles matter that is able to constitute a situation-level actuality2bm. Note the precise definition of the term, “entanglement”. Entanglement is like a substance, but it occurs when form attracts or engages matter (other than the originating matter). Here, content-level form2af entangles the matter of a principle of unity2bm. The form2af is not like an aggregate of parts. The form2af is a whole2bm.
An actuality that contains a substance and an entanglement is technically labeled, “a confounding”.
0097 Here is a picture of the content-level confounding and its resolution.

The resolution yields a noumenon, a thing itself, that is bigger than the little noumenon.

0098 On the situation-level, the matter of a principle of unity2bm substantiates the form of an embodiment2bf. In archaeology, this embodiment2bf might be a tool or an artifact. Both dwell in the situation-level normal context of identity3b and emerge from the potential of ‘power’1b.
0099 The story does not stop at the sensible construction of a bigger noumenon.
The situation-level form2bf can entangle matter that is able to sustain a perspective-level thing.
In this case, embodiment2bf entangles a perspective-level process2cm, addressing the question, “How do we do things?”.

0100 The matter of process2cm then substantiates the form of construction2cf, which could be regarded as a cultural phenomenon (since it theoretically can be observed by anthropologists). The normal context is cultural activity3c and the potential is ‘virtually contextualizing identity’1c. Both people and artifacts participate in the situation-level category-based nested form. Both are contextualized by cultural activities3c.
0101 Here is a noumenon that is bigger than the big noumenon.

0102 This quick overview shows that the bigger noumenon is the product of the resolution of two confoundings, each with its own entanglement and resolution.






















