Looking at Alva Noe’s Book (2023) “Entanglement” (Part 7 of 24)
0079 My disquisition (E) demonstrates that a Peircean formulation of “entanglement”, using Aristotle’s terminology, may be relevant to Dr. Noe’s personal journey. After all, a theologian, an artist and a philosopher are already prepared to tell a listener that revelation, art and philosophy make us what we are.
Well, they make us who we are.
0080 Before starting his journey, what was Dr. Noe?
Was he a cog in the machinery of the philosophy department at UC Berkeley, the Center of New Media, and the Program in Critical Theory?
It does not require a theologian, an artist or a philosopher to draw that conclusion.
0081 My disquisition (E) begins to show who Dr. Noe may be.
0082 As noted earlier, the aspect-shift is familiar to researchers in cognitive psychology.
The disquisition (E) shows that the word, “science”, pictures and points to two very different aspects.
0083 The first aspect is the practice of empirical science as a content-level activity2a, bereft of a situation-level. This is where scientists3a – as crazy people fritting about their laboratories1a – want to be. They just want to conduct the research that they are interested in2a.
0084 Here is a picture of the unfolded Positivist’s judgment, adjusted to show a reified empirio-schematic judgment appropriate to a particular scientific inquiry.

Note that the thing2a of natural science contains disciplinary language and data as matter2am and mathematical and mechanical models as form2af. That is how research is conducted.
0085 Step back and an obvious problem (or entanglement) appears.
The (adjusted) unfolded Positivist’s judgment (as content) needs to be situated.
Triumphalist scientists have successfully exploited the opportunity, by insisting that the unfolded empirio-schematic judgment should serve as a situation-level nested form.
0086 The resulting practice of triumphalist science (also called “laboratory science”) follows.

Note that the thing2a of laboratory science contains mathematics and mechanics as matter2am and disciplinary language and data as form2af.
This constitutes the second aspect.
0087 If one considers a particular scientific inquiry, then one aspect-shifts from natural science to laboratory science. The content-level thing shifts with the aspect.
In chapter twelve (C12), the author draws an unexpected conclusion about a drawing that produces an optical illusion.
The expected conclusion says that, with binocular-rivalry, consciousness reports either a rabbit or a duck.
With aspect-shift, there is an unexpected option. The state of aspect shift cannot be ignored when a confounding does not resolve.
0088 What does that imply?
The either-or of natural or laboratory science engages this third state, the state of the aspect shifting back and forth. Triumphalist science resolves a confounding and ends the state of aspect shifting. The first aspect goes with the (adjusted) Positivist’s judgment as unsituated content. The second aspect goes with the triumphalist empirio-schematic judgment as that which situates the (adjusted) Positivist’s judgment.
0089 To me, Noe’s unexpected realization suggests (F) that Peirce’s entanglement complements the author’s use of the term.
At this juncture, my disquisition into Peirce’s formulation of substance, entanglement and confounding may clarify who Dr. Noe is. The author is not talking about the practice of natural science. The author is escaping laboratory science.
0090 Next, I will sketch Peirce’s formulation and develop different sizes for Aristotle’s noumenon.


























