Looking at Alva Noe’s Book (2023) “Entanglement” (Part 9 of 24)
0103 Chapter one (C1) is titled “Art in Mind”.
0104 The author quotes one of his favorite British philosophers, R. G. Collingwood (1899-1943), who translated Benedetto Croce’s book The Philosophy of Giambattista Vico into English.
Vico (1668-1744) was an Italian philosopher who wrote, among other books, The New Science, as a rejection of Descartes’ mechanical philosophy. Vico is not a scholastic, even though he writes at in the twilight of the Latin Age and the dawn of the Age of Ideas. The New Science presents a history of ideas.
Benedetto Croce (1866-1952) is an Italian humanist whose family was killed by the Casamiccola earthquake near Naples in 1883. Collingwood is one or two generations younger that Croce. During their lives, discoveries in paleolithic and neolithic archaeology make headlines. The Altamira cave in Spain is investigated in 1879. The Lascaux cave in France is discovered in 1940.
0105 Of course, Paleolithic art captures the imagination of thinkers like Collingwood.
These modernists wonder, “What were these cave-painters thinking?
Paleolithic cave art literally pictures and points to various animals, as if the painted animals are the referents of manual-brachial word-gestures. The referents are what the artists are thinking. The paintings are like manual-brachial word-gestures that picture and point to their referents.
0106 Collingwood suggested that Paleolithic rock art and writing might have ‘something’ in common. They do, when the writing is ideographic. Chinese, Egyptian and early Sumerian scripts originate because they picture (and point to) their referents, just like Paleolithic rock art and hand-talk. At the same time, these ancient scripts add something to their spoken language. Writing adorns spoken words by immortalizing them.
0107 So, why should speech not have originally adorned hand-talk, which images and indicates its referents, even when routinized as gesture-words?
Razie Mah discusses this possibility in his e-book, Synaesthesia and the Bicameral Mind in Human Evolution, which refines blogs that appear on his website in October and November, 2025.
Isn’t “art” all about adornment as an organizing principle?
0108 How could speech have evolved as an adornment to hand talk?
I start with a picture of the bigger noumenon, where only one slot, the little noumenon, consists of hand-talk. To appreciate the evolution of hand talk, consider Razie Mah’s e-books, The Human Niche and Comments on Michael Tomasello’s Arc of Inquiry (1999-2019). Speech is added to hand talk with the evolution of our own species, Homo sapiens, around 300 kyr (kilos of years ago).

0109 Consider hand-talk as a motivated (not arbitrary) relation between two systems of differences, langue (the referent that can be pictured and pointed to) and parole (the manual-brachial gesture that pictures and points). The motivation exploits the semiotic character of manual-brachial gestures operating as icons and indexes (two of the three natural sign-relations listed by Charles Peirce (1839-1914)). The conventional aspects of the relation operate as symbols (the third natural sign-relation). So, hand-talk langue is perceived as an icon and index, but it functions as symbol, because a symbol is a sign-relation whose sign-object is grounded in habit and convention and so forth.
0110 Langue (the referent) serves as matter that substantiates parole (the form of a manual-brachial gesture).
0111 What does the form2af entangle?
In human evolution, why does hand-talk2af entangle the voice as matter (that associates to a principle of unity2bm)?
As one expects for the big noumenon, manual-brachial word-gestures2af should entangle a principle of unity. What happens under conditions when it is difficult to rapidly (conventionally) read manual-brachial gestures? The principle of unity2bm should substantiate an embodiment2bf under these circumstances.
A communal story hand-talked at night, in the dancing illumination of a campfire, may serve as an example. The voice had been coming under voluntary control as an adaptation for singing, so it makes sense that the voice could serve as the principle of unity2am that substantiates… what we presently call… “speech”2bf. The vocal adornment2bm isolates the form of a gestural word2af during these special communal moments. The voice2bf and the word-gesture2af work together.
0112 The confounding resolves as follows.

0113 On the content-level, the normal context of hand-talk (structure)3a brings the dyadic actuality of fully linguistic hand-talk2a into relation with the potential of ‘Peirce’s three types of natural sign-relations’1a.
Then, on the situation-level, the voice has the power1b to adorn each hand-talk word2bm in order to identify the gesture2af under less than optimal visual circumstances. If that is not aesthetic work3b, I don’t know what is.























